December 2016

abstract

Gérer & Comprendre

Full issue

Issue 126

OVERLOOKED…

Managing the physical appearance of the personnel of luxury hotels who are in contact with customers

By Nathalie Montargot ,
PhD in Managerial Sciences, adjunct professor Groupe Sup de Co La Rochelle (France), laboratoire CEREGE Poitiers

Managing “looks” is a major issue in organizations that try to control their image. A review of the literature shows that the physical appearance of the personnel in contact with customers has a positive influence on the latter in terms of credibility, friendliness, competence, empathy and courtesy. Customers notice “experiential cues” – various sensations (visual, auditive, olfactive, tactile) – from the personnel with whom they enter into contact, and use these cues to evaluate services. Few studies have been made from the manager’s viewpoint of the issue of the personnel’s physical appearance. Borrowing the grid of interpretation designed from studies of customer reactions but shifting focus to managers’ perceptions, this research has formulated two questions. On what sensorial data are managers’ perceptions of their employees’ physical appearance based? To what extent do managers encounter difficulty seeing to it that the establishment’s norms are followed? Various sources (the literature on human resource management, the marketing of services and labor sociology) are reviewed with a focus on employees’ physical appearances and the organization’s dress code. A qualitative methodology was designed through an exploratory survey of twenty luxury hotel managers, who oversee the impressions made on customers and the effects on their symbolic social status. This survey’s findings shed light on the complexity and scope of the “competence of service”, and on the difficulty that managers have of managing the personnel’s physical appearance. As these findings confirm, it is necessary to take into account the emotional, social and physical dimensions of prescribed roles. The sensorial cues perceived by managers are but partly the same as those perceived by customers. The interest of managers, as directors of a stage where services are produced, is to help the personnel have a “reflexive distance” from their prescribed role and from customers’ perceptions. Recommendations are made for support through the formation of a “working community” and training programs to heighten the awareness of sensorial, experiential cues.

TRIAL BY FACT

Organizational reliability seen through interstitial activities

By Jérémy EYDIEUX
Doctorant, sciences de gestion à l’école des mines de Nantes, Institut Mines-Télécom

Benoît JOURNÉ
Professeur des Universités, sciences de gestion à l’Université de Nantes (IEMN-IAE) et professeur associé à l’école des mines de Nantes, Institut Mines-Télécom

and Stéphanie TILLEMENT
Maître-assistant, sociologie industrielle à l’école des mines de Nantes, Institut Mines-Télécom

Most empirical studies of organizational reliability have focused on the most visible activities directly related to reliability: deck-landings on aircraft carriers, the operation and maintenance of nuclear power stations, emergency services and operating rooms… Herein, focus is shifted to “interstitial” activities on the borderline with these visible activities. During fieldwork in the nuclear industry, heavy handling operations were analyzed from an approach based on pragmatic theories and the plant’s actions in communications. An original definition of interstitial activities is proposed based on four observable characteristics. These activities have effects on the alarm system for intrusions and exchanges between departments, thus reinforcing then organization’s reliability as a whole. The concept of “interstitial activity” makes a contribution to research on “distributed organizations”, in which the articulation of boundaries is conceived in relation to managerial arrangements, objects and individuals. free download

Higher education: Myths and facts of the digital revolution

By Samia GHOZLANE
International University of Monaco, INSEEC Research Center

Aude DEVILLE
Université de Nice-IAE, GRM, INSEEC Business School, INSEEC Research Center

and Hervé DUMEZ
Institut interdisciplinaire de l’innovation (UMR 9217), i3-Centre de recherche en gestion, École polytechnique

A review of the literature and empirical data collected through semidirective interviews are the grounds for this analysis of the impact of digitalization on higher education. Attention is turned, in particular, to changes in teaching in schools of management and to the relations between faculty organizations and students. In coping with this new trend, which might turn out to be a mere fad, questions arise about the legitimacy of business schools. Three points are made about: 1) the effect of mimesis in organizations faced with digitalization; 2) the new quest for legitimacy by organizations; and 3) potential changes in their business models.

Professors reinvented: The “Smarty” revolution!

By Sarah Alves ,
dean of EM Normandie,

and Laurence Hélène ,
head of the third year of the Programme Grandes Écoles, EM Normandie

In the future, teachers will guide students “in a learning process using Internet resources” ( Le Monde , 2013). Since the digital era has a strong impact on the teaching profession, how to identify the actual results of introducing a “learner-centered” approach and digital technology in higher education, specifically schools of management? Little has been written on this topic. Based on a cognitive-map methodology, this empirical study shows the effects of digitalization on activities, aptitudes and, above all, positions: teachers in higher education are becoming genuine tutors through their educational actions. It will be necessary to redesign the system for training, both initially and throughout careers, professors and researchers in educational methods and teaching skills.

The conditions of success for sponsorship: The followup on young graduates by the association NQT

By Damien COLLARD
Maître de conférences, Université de Franche-Comté, et chercheur - Centre de recherche en gestion des organisations de l’Université de Bourgogne

Nathalie RAULET-CROSET
Maître de conférences, IAE de Paris de l’Université Paris 1, et chercheure - Centre de recherche en gestion de l’École polytechnique

Jean-Baptiste SUQUET
Professeur associé, Neoma Business School, et chercheur associé - Institut de recherche en gestion de l’Université Paris-Est Marne-la-Vallée

and Laure AMAR
Ingénieur d’étude, Centre de recherche en gestion de l’École polytechnique

A program of sponsorship is presented that follows up on young graduates from higher education who are looking for or returning to work. It seeks to facilitate access to the world of work for certain categories of youth and fight against discrimination. A “research-action” program, conducted at the request of an association that brings young graduates into contact with persons working in firms, has identified four major psychosocial motivations of the sponsorship relation: 1) the “Wow!” effect”, 2) the Pygmalion effect, 3) the improvement of relational skills, and 4) the network effect. Taken together, they form a “magic square” of sponsorship. free download

IN QUEST OF A THEORY

Regulating toxic substances “without data”: The genealogy of REACH’s “prohibition through authorization”

By Henri Boullier ,
PhD in Sociology and postdoctoral research IFRIS at the Centre de Recherche Médecine, Sciences, Santé, Santé Mentale, Société (CERMES3)

How to control high-risk substances despite the lack, incompleteness or confidentiality of the data available, but unequally, to authorities and companies? Starting with an analysis of the US Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976, the problems are described that public authorities have encountered while trying to control the tens of thousands of chemicals on the market. In the United States as in the European Union, the asymmetry of information between authorities and firms ended, for a long time, in a deadlock. The adoption of the European REACH regulation in 2006 has lifted this blockage. Its “authorization” procedure enables authorities to regulate dangerous molecules without new data by placing on firms the burden of proving that they control health risks and that the chemicals they deem essential to their business are economically useful. REACH is thus involved in regulating high-risk merchandise, in particular owing to its “prohibition through authorization”, which prefers a gradual withdrawal of the most dangerous substances from the marketplace to an outright prohibition. free download

Mosaics

Domesticated creativity

On Adam Grant’s, Originals: How non-conformists move the world (New York: Viking, 2016).

By Céline Flipo

Managing nonprofit organizations

On Julien Bernet, Philippe Eynaud, Olivier Maurel and Corinne Vercher-Chaptal’s, La Gestion des associations (Paris: érès, 2016).

By Patrick Gilbert

Theories about organizations – New turning points

On François-Xavier de Vaujany, Anthony Hussenot and Jean-François Chanlat’s, Théories des organisations – Nouveaux tournants (Paris, Economica, 2016).

By Yvon Pesqueux

Bureaucracy

On David Graeber’s Bureaucratie (Paris: Éditions Les Liens Qui Libèrent, 2015).

By Jean-Marc Weller

La revue complète

Version française

Retour en haut